Thought Process
Here’s a breakdown of the thought process to solve this problem:
- Understand the Physics: The core concept is gas escaping through an orifice. This immediately brings to mind concepts from fluid dynamics, particularly flow through a nozzle or small opening. Since the pressure difference is significant (1 atm down to 0.3 atm), we can expect choked flow initially.
- Identify Key Variables and Parameters: List what’s given and what we need to find.
- Given:
- Cylinder dimensions: length (L = 50 m), diameter (D = 4 m)
- Initial conditions: temperature (T = 20°C), pressure (P_i = 101.3 kPa)
- Final pressure: P_f = 0.3 * 101.3 kPa
- Hole diameter: d = 1 cm = 0.01 m
- To Find:
- Time (t) to reach the final pressure.
- How the time changes with hole diameter.
- Given:
- Make Simplifying Assumptions: Real-world scenarios are complex. To make the problem tractable, we need simplifications:
- Ideal Gas: Assume the air behaves as an ideal gas. This allows us to use the ideal gas law (PV = nRT).
- Isothermal Process: Assume the temperature remains constant during the depressurization. This is a reasonable first approximation, especially for a large volume. Heat transfer from the structure might compensate for cooling due to expansion.
- Quasi-steady Flow: Assume the outflow rate is instantaneous and depends on the current pressure inside the station. This allows us to model the process as a series of small time steps where the conditions are approximately constant.
- Sharp-Edged Orifice: Assume the hole behaves like a sharp-edged orifice, allowing us to use standard flow coefficients.
- Neglect Viscosity (Initially): Focus on the dominant effect of pressure difference.
- Develop the Model:
- Calculate Volume: Find the volume of the cylinder (V = πr²h).
- Relate Pressure Change to Mass Change: Using the ideal gas law, relate the change in pressure to the change in the number of moles (or mass) of air inside. Since T and V are constant, ΔP is directly proportional to Δn (or Δm).
- Determine Outflow Rate: Apply the concept of flow through an orifice. Initially, the flow is likely choked (the pressure ratio across the hole is high). The mass flow rate depends on the upstream pressure, the area of the hole, and properties of the gas. Later, as the pressure drops, the flow may become subsonic.
- Formulate a Differential Equation: Express the rate of change of pressure (dP/dt) in terms of the outflow rate. This will involve the volume of the station.
- Integrate the Differential Equation: Solve the differential equation to find the time as a function of the initial and final pressures and the parameters of the system.
- Address Different Flow Regimes (Choked vs. Subsonic):
- Choked Flow: Occurs when the pressure ratio (P_external / P_internal) is below a critical value (approximately 0.528 for air). The flow velocity at the throat of the hole is sonic, and the mass flow rate is independent of the downstream pressure.
- Subsonic Flow: Occurs when the pressure ratio is higher than the critical value. The flow velocity is below sonic, and the mass flow rate depends on both upstream and downstream pressures.
- Detailed Calculations (with Choked Flow Assumption initially):
- Area of the hole (A).
- Speed of sound in air (c).
- Mass flow rate (ṁ) using the choked flow equation.
- Relate mass flow rate to the rate of change of pressure using the ideal gas law.
- Integrate the resulting differential equation.
- Refine the Model (Considering Subsonic Flow Later):
- Realize that as the pressure drops, the flow will transition from choked to subsonic.
- Use the subsonic flow equation when the pressure ratio is above the critical value.
- This will require either solving a more complex integral or using a numerical approach (breaking the process into small time steps).
- Analyze the Effect of Hole Diameter:
- Observe that the mass flow rate is proportional to the area of the hole (which is proportional to the square of the diameter).
- Conclude that the time to depressurize will be inversely proportional to the area of the hole (or inversely proportional to the square of the diameter).
- Structure the Answer:
- Start with the assumptions made.
- Detail the calculations, including formulas and steps.
- Explicitly address the choked flow regime and its impact.
- Explain how the time varies with hole diameter.
- Discuss limitations and potential improvements to the model.
Self-Correction/Refinement During the Process:
- Initial thought: Maybe Bernoulli’s principle directly applies. Correction: Bernoulli’s principle is for incompressible fluids. Here, we have significant pressure changes and gas expansion, so we need to consider compressibility and choked flow.
- Initial thought: Assume constant outflow rate. Correction: The outflow rate depends on the pressure difference, which changes over time. Therefore, the outflow rate is not constant, and we need to integrate.
- Initial calculation: Using a simplified flow equation without considering the adiabatic index. Correction: The adiabatic index is important for choked flow calculations. Ensure the correct formula is used.
- Realization: The transition from choked to subsonic flow is crucial for accurate results, especially as the pressure difference decreases.
By following this systematic approach, including identifying key concepts, making simplifying assumptions, developing the model, performing calculations, and refining the approach as needed, we can arrive at a comprehensive and accurate answer to the problem.
Solution
Assumptions:
- Ideal Gas: We’ll assume the air inside the space station behaves as an ideal gas.
- Isothermal Process: We’ll assume the temperature of the air remains constant at 20°C during the depressurization. This is a simplification, as the expanding gas would cool, but for a rough estimate, it’s reasonable.
- Sharp-Edged Orifice: We’ll treat the hole as a sharp-edged orifice, allowing us to use standard flow coefficients.
- Negligible External Pressure: We’re assuming the pressure outside the space station is negligible compared to the inside pressure.
Calculations:
- Calculate the Volume of the Space Station:
- Radius (r) = Diameter / 2 = 4 m / 2 = 2 m
- Volume (V) = π * r² * length = π * (2 m)² * 50 m = 200π ≈ 628.32 m³
- Calculate the Area of the Hole:
- Radius of the hole (r_h) = Diameter of the hole / 2 = 1 cm / 2 = 0.5 cm = 0.005 m
- Area of the hole (A) = π * r_h² = π * (0.005 m)² = 7.854 x 10⁻⁵ m²
- Consider the Outflow Rate:
The outflow of gas through a small hole can be approximated using the principles of fluid dynamics. For a significant pressure difference (as we have here initially), the flow will be choked, meaning the air velocity at the hole reaches the speed of sound. The mass flow rate (ṁ) can be estimated by:ṁ = C_d * A * √(γ * ρ * P)Where:- ṁ is the mass flow rate ( kg/s )
- C_d is the discharge coefficient (approximately 0.6-0.8 for a sharp-edged orifice, let’s use 0.7)
- A is the area of the hole (m²)
- γ is the adiabatic index for air (approximately 1.4)
- ρ is the density of the air ( kg/m ³)
- P is the pressure inside the space station (Pa)
- Calculate the Initial Density of the Air:
Using the ideal gas law (PV = nRT or P = ρRT/M, where M is the molar mass of air):- ρ = PM / (RT)
- P = 101300 Pa
- M (molar mass of air) ≈ 0.028964 kg/mol
- R (ideal gas constant) = 8.314 J/(mol·K)
- T = 20°C + 273.15 = 293.15 K
- ρ = (101300 Pa * 0.028964 kg/mol ) / (8.314 J/(mol·K) * 293.15 K) ≈ 1.204 kg/m ³
- Set up the Differential Equation:
The rate of change of mass inside the space station is equal to the negative of the mass flow rate:dM/dt = -ṁThe mass of air inside is M = ρV. Assuming the volume remains constant, dM/dt = V * dρ/dt. We can also relate the change in density to the change in pressure using the ideal gas law (assuming constant temperature): dρ/dt = (M/(RT)) * dP/dt.Combining these, we get:V * (M/(RT)) * dP/dt = – C_d * A * √(γ * (MP/(RT)) * P)Simplifying:dP/dt = – (C_d * A * √(γ * R * T / M)) * (P / V) * √P
dP/dt = – K * P^(3/2)Where K = (C_d * A * √(γ * R * T / M)) / V is a constant. - Solve the Differential Equation:
Separate variables and integrate:∫(from P_initial to P_final) dP / P^(3/2) = ∫(from 0 to t) -K dt[-2 * P^(-1/2)] (from P_initial to P_final) = -Kt2 * (1/√P_initial – 1/√P_final) = Ktt = (2 / K) * (1/√P_initial – 1/√P_final) - Calculate K:
- K = (0.7 * 7.854 x 10⁻⁵ m² * √(1.4 * 8.314 J/(mol·K) * 293.15 K / 0.028964 kg/mol )) / 628.32 m³
- K ≈ (0.7 * 7.854 x 10⁻⁵ * √(100678.8)) / 628.32
- K ≈ (0.7 * 7.854 x 10⁻⁵ * 317.3) / 628.32
- K ≈ 1.744 x 10⁻⁵ s⁻¹ Pa⁻¹/²
- Calculate the Time (t):
- P_initial = 101300 Pa
- P_final = 0.3 * 101300 Pa = 30390 Pa
- t = (2 / 1.744 x 10⁻⁵ s⁻¹ Pa⁻¹/²) * (1/√101300 Pa – 1/√30390 Pa)
- t ≈ 114678.8 Pa¹/² s * (0.003144 Pa⁻¹/² – 0.005725 Pa⁻¹/²)
- t ≈ 114678.8 * (-0.002581) s
- t ≈ -295.9 s
- t ≈ 114678.8 Pa¹/² s * (0.005725 Pa⁻¹/² – 0.003144 Pa⁻¹/²)
- t ≈ 114678.8 * (0.002581) s
- t ≈ 295.9 seconds
How the Time Differs for Different Hole Diameters:
The area of the hole (A) is proportional to the square of the diameter (d²). Looking at the constant K:
K ∝ A ∝ d²
Since the time (t) is inversely proportional to K:
t ∝ 1/K ∝ 1/d²
Therefore:
- Larger Hole Diameter: A larger hole diameter will result in a significantly faster depressurization. The time taken will be inversely proportional to the square of the diameter. If you double the diameter of the hole, the area increases by a factor of 4, and the depressurization time will be approximately four times shorter.
- Smaller Hole Diameter: A smaller hole diameter will result in a significantly slower depressurization.
Important Considerations and Limitations:
- Choked Flow Assumption: We initially assumed choked flow. As the pressure inside the station drops, the flow might transition to subsonic flow. This more complex scenario would require a different flow equation and likely numerical integration for an exact solution. However, for a significant initial pressure difference, the choked flow assumption is a good starting point.
- Isothermal Assumption: In reality, the expanding air would cool down (adiabatic expansion). This would affect the density and the speed of sound, influencing the outflow rate. A more accurate model would involve energy balance considerations.
- Discharge Coefficient (C_d): The value of the discharge coefficient can vary depending on the shape and sharpness of the hole.
- External Pressure: If the pressure outside the space station is not negligible, the pressure difference driving the flow would be smaller, and the depressurization would take longer.
In summary, for a 1 cm hole, it would take approximately 5 minutes for the pressure to drop to 0.3 atmospheres. The time taken is inversely proportional to the square of the hole’s diameter.
You may also like:
